Originally by J.J. Cale
After Midnight is a cover song performed by Phish that has been performed 8 times since its debut on December 31, 1999 at Big Cypress Seminole Indian Reservation. It has been played at 7 different venues, with the longest known version lasting 11:16. The current gap is 279 shows since the last performance. On average, it appears every 97 shows. This song is currently considered a bustout candidate due to an unusually long gap.